AliCommerce is a Pirated Version of BV Commerce

My name is Marcus McConnell. I am the president, founder and lead developer of BV Software, a company I started in 2001 in Richmond, Virginia. BV Commerce is our main application. It’s an asp.net ecommerce software product that has gone through 5 releases in the 8 years that I have put into this company. We were the first commercial asp.net ecommerce solution ever released. We have several thousand stores running on BV Commerce, and this has been my life’s work for the last eight years. We are a small company competing with much bigger companies that just tries to create good software for web merchants and developers. We are also an established company that has numerous well-known clients as has won several industry awards.

For years I’d thought about building a DotNetNuke e-commerce module, but just didn’t have the time. When you are a small business owner, you have to wear a lot of hats. Yesterday I finally decided to investigate what it would take to build such a module and in the process I downloaded AliCommerce to see what my ‘competitor’ had created.

As I looked through the software I realized with horror that AliCommerce was actually BV Commerce. Since I am the chief architect and wrote the majority of the code myself, it was easy to see that AliCommerce was a blatant theft of our code. The man selling this software, Frank Wang, actually purchased BV Commerce several months before each new ‘release’ of AliCommerce and then stripped our branding and resold it.

This is not a developer dispute. We have no affiliation or association with Frank Wang or AliCommerce whatsoever. What he did was totally illegal. He did not have permission to rebrand our software and sell it as his own. I have attached the receipts as well as the unmitigated proof in photos of how AliCommerce is a direct theft of BvCommerce. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions about this or require any further proof.

Pirated software is a fact of life on the internet, but I am shocked and disheartened to realize that this theft has been going on for over two years now. Countless merchants are now running illegal copies of my software, and those merchants, as well as the DotNetNuke community should be as angry as I am that we have been stolen from and lied to. I might never have noticed this theft at all if I hadn’t decided to build a DotNetNuke ecommerce module myself.

I am currently trying to resolve this situation. As the AliCommerce website is listed in Australia and China it seems highly unlikely that I will ever receive any recompense for this theft, but I need to make AliCommerce customers know that they are running illegal software and that what they are using is bastardized software that does not accurately reflect what BV Commerce has to offer.

This is a more than unfortunate situation, it has damaged myself, my company, and countless DNN community members but I want to try and find some way to make lemonade out of lemons. I hope that the DotNetNuke team will help us get the word out to their users who have been lied to and stolen from so that we can look forward to an ecommerce solution for DNN that users can trust.

If you are an AliCommerce customer, please look at the attached proof that you are running illegal software, and please fill out the contact form below so that we can keep you updated about the situation. If you register with us, we will not prosecute you. You are victims as much as we are. But we need your help to resolve this issue and try to minimize the damages that have already been done. Please help us go forward and create an official legal version of BvCommerce for DotNetNuke that we can all be proud of.

Marcus McConnell
Founder and President, BV Software

Name:  
Company:
Email:  
Subject:
Message
   


 
 
 

How do you know that AliCommerce is really BV Commerce?

Here is just a small portion of our evidence supporting our claim that AliCommerce is really just an illegally repackaged version of BV Commerce 2004 and BV Commerce 5.

  • Xinshu (Frank) Wang's Purchase receipt of BVC 2004 Dated 7/17/2005, well before the first release of AliCommerce
  • Frank's Purchase receipt of BV Commece 5 Dated 9/2/2006, well before the second release of AliCommerce
  • A document comparing screenshots of AliCommerce 2 to BV Commerce 2004 and BV Commerce 5.
  • The source code modules contain the exact same method names, signatures and structure as BV Commerce 5.
  • The database tables are almost identical to BV Commerce tables.
  • The database tables use GUID values for unique Ids. AliCommerce is the only other ASP.NET software we have encountered that also uses GUID values.
  • Several DNN community members who spoke with us about AliCommerce were surprised by the quick development time for AliCommerce. They had doubts that a single person could generate the volume and quality of code in the time given.
  • The FileIcon and Message icon images exactly match the BV Commerce file names.
  • The HTML field properties for pages like the GoogleBase feed are extactly 200px wide with drop down list selections identical to BV Commerce.
  • The web site folder structure for the admin is idential to BV Commerce with the same language
    • Catalog
    • Controls
    • Customers (people)
    • Dashboard
    • Marketing
    • Orders
    • Settings
  • AliCommerce uses "Vendor" and "Manufacturer" for suppliers just like BV Commerce. No other ecommerce pacakge uses exactly these two terms for suppliers.
  • The reports shipped with AliCommerce are DailySales, SalesByDate, TopCustomers, TopProducts exactly the same reports from BV Commerce
  • The category layouts in AliCommerce are Detailed List, Grid List, Grid List with Subs, Simple List, exactly the same category layouts as BV Commerce
  • The list goes on and on like this...